Trader consensus on Polymarket assigns a 98% implied probability to "No" for Jesus Christ's return before 2027, driven by the complete absence of verifiable biblical signs—such as global tribulation, the Antichrist's rise, or cosmic portents—in recent months, alongside two millennia of unfulfilled apocalyptic predictions that have conditioned cultural skepticism. A brief viral buzz in February 2026 doubled Yes odds to 4% amid social media memes and a speculative poll, but rational traders quickly arbitraged it back, with over $62 million in volume underscoring skin-in-the-game conviction. Realistic upsets would require an unambiguous, globally witnessed supernatural event validated by credible reporting consensus before December 31, 2026, though such low-probability black swans remain culturally improbable.